Cheapest Cars With the Best MPG of 2023

Many of the cheapest cars have the best gas mileage for their respective segments, as they seek to attract buyers who can’t afford a lot upfront or too many long-term expenses. These types of vehicles need to stand the test of time while still retaining their value. Luckily, they come in all shapes and sizes, which makes it easy for consumers to find the perfect fit.

This is a list of the most affordable, fuel-efficient cars available in the USA for 2023.

BuzzScore
Design
Performance
MPG
Interior
Infotainment
Reliability
Safety
Value
#1
2023 Hyundai Kona N
9.4
BuzzScore
9
Design
10
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#2
2023 Kia Sorento
9.3
BuzzScore
9
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
10
Value
#3
2023 Kia Carnival
9.3
BuzzScore
10
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
10
Value
#4
2023 Hyundai Santa Fe
9.1
BuzzScore
9
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#5
2023 Hyundai Elantra N
9.1
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
9
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#6
2023 Ford F-150
9.1
BuzzScore
8
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
10
Infotainment
10
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#7
2023 Mazda CX-30
9
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
9
MPG
9
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#8
2023 Hyundai Tucson
9
BuzzScore
10
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
10
Infotainment
10
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#9
2023 Toyota GR86
9
BuzzScore
10
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#10
2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 LTD
9
BuzzScore
8
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
10
Reliability
8
Safety
10
Value
#11
2022 Hyundai Veloster N
8.9
BuzzScore
10
Design
10
Performance
6
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#12
2023 Kia Sportage
8.6
BuzzScore
7
Design
8
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#13
2023 Chevrolet Traverse
8.6
BuzzScore
8
Design
7
Performance
8
MPG
10
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
9
Safety
9
Value
#14
2023 Subaru Impreza Hatchback
8.5
BuzzScore
8
Design
7
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
8
Infotainment
10
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#15
2023 Ford Mustang Convertible
8.5
BuzzScore
8
Design
7
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
10
Safety
9
Value
#16
2023 Nissan Frontier
8.4
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
7
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
8
Value
#17
2022 GMC Sierra 1500 Limited
8.4
BuzzScore
7
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
8
Interior
9
Infotainment
10
Reliability
8
Safety
8
Value
#18
2023 Dodge Challenger
8.4
BuzzScore
8
Design
7
Performance
9
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
7
Reliability
9
Safety
8
Value
#19
2023 Subaru BRZ
8.3
BuzzScore
9
Design
8
Performance
7
MPG
8
Interior
8
Infotainment
9
Reliability
8
Safety
9
Value
#20
2024 Dodge Hornet
8.3
BuzzScore
9
Design
9
Performance
8
MPG
9
Interior
10
Infotainment
7
Reliability
7
Safety
7
Value

Characteristics of Affordable Cars with Good Gas Mileage

Cheap, fuel-efficient cars generally tick the bare minimum number of boxes to give the best value for the lowest investment.

  • They cost very little both upfront and in the long run
  • They don’t have all that much power on tap
  • They are easy to handle and relatively comfortable
  • They often come with solid warranty plans

What to Consider When Buying Cheap Fuel-efficient Cars

There are plenty of cheap cars with good gas mileage in the US, sourced both locally and abroad to give consumers the best value. But, you have to be sure when buying a cheap car that you actually are getting a good deal or if you’d be better off spending a little more.

Pros

  • Highly affordable base price
  • Generally quite practical and easy to live with
  • They retain their value even after several years
  • Good warranty and reliability ratings
  • They cost less at the pumps (obviously)

Cons

  • Low-powered engines
  • Hit-and-miss safety ratings
  • Cost-cutting can hurt overall quality

FAQs

What are the cheapest cars with the best gas mileage?

A perfect combination of these two qualities, the Kia Rio costs well below $20,000, and it still manages to achieve 32/41 mpg city/highway. The Nissan Versa is even cheaper and almost matches these figures. However, it is the Mitsubishi Mirage that achieves the best 36/43 mpg, though we have a hard time calling it one of the best models as a complete package as it tends to skimp on other fronts to make it cheap and efficient.

What is the price of the most affordable cars with good gas mileage?

The Nissan Versa Sedan is the most affordable at just shy of $16,000 MSRP, while the Mitsubishi Mirage is slightly more expensive. A new Hyundai Accent and Kia Rio will cost you around $18k.

How far can the cheapest, most fuel-efficient cars travel?

The Kia Rio and Hyundai Accent each have 11.9-gallon tanks, and to make up for their low fuel economy, the Kia Soul boasts 14.3 gallons of fuel capacity. This allows each model to cover almost 430 miles on a full tank.

How reliable are cheap, fuel-efficient cars?

Generally speaking, most automakers of cheap cars with the best mpg have garnered excellent reputations for reliability, though there are some exceptions, so be sure to check recalls and complaints, as well as warrant plans, before you buy.
Back
To Top